Susan Robb Is Going from Mexico to Canada Like No Artist Has Gone Before
On her five-month walk along the Pacific Crest Trail, the artist is Instagramming nature, replicating rocks, and Facebooking the sublime. Why on earth would someone go out into the wild to blog?
It wasn’t funny, it was unthinkable.
Two days earlier, Robb and her crew had been walking in 102-degree heat. Now it was 25 degrees. They all looked up to the sky. No joke. It was coming down. They pulled out their maps and tried to figure out what to do. Robb was somewhere in the middle of the San Bernardino Mountains, in the wilds of Southern California—she’s an artist who lives in Seattle, so she was in unfamiliar territory. She was about 40 days into a five-and-a-half-month trek from Mexico to Canada on foot, following the Pacific Crest Trail. The trek isn’t just for health or adventure, it’s a highly coordinated art project called Wild Times.
On a map, Robb and her crew found a dot indicating the nearest stopping place—something called Coon Creek Cabin. To get there would require walking 10 steep miles uphill. They had no choice. They piled on rain clothes and pulled socks onto their hands for mittens and started the trudge.
After a few hours, it started to get dark. The path was covered in parts by snow; at times, they had no idea whether they were headed in the right direction. By the time they saw the cabin, one hiker started hallucinating. He thought he smelled fire. But the cabin contained only mouse droppings, about 10 other shivering hikers on a bare floor, and cruel signs saying fires were forbidden.
Their home for the night wasn’t so much a cabin as a shelter. “The doors and windows are all open holes,” Robb noted. There were snowdrifts inside.
When the sky turns as white as a frozen-solid lake and you’re nowhere near warmth, when you spend a night entombed by the darkness of a desert, when you’re detoured because another hiker’s dead dehydrated body is being helicoptered away from the main route, when a mountain suddenly rises into view larger than any god or monster—this is the category of experience known as the “sublime.” It’s so intense that people want to experience it over and over, except usually without the danger. This is where artists of all kinds come in, with huge, vertiginous, stark paintings and photographs and films.
That’s not what Robb does. Robb has been responding to the sublime by Facebooking, Instagramming, tweeting, blogging, and transmitting instructions to 3-D printers elsewhere. She set out on the Pacific Crest Trail equipped with an iPhone and a digital camera, and she has been sending back dispatches since (find them at wildtimesproject.com).
We know the Coon Creek Cabin had the words “DEAD” and “Anne Frank was here” carved into it because Robb included photos in a blog post she wrote about it after a very cold night’s sleep. She slept wearing “every inch of clothing” she had with her. She titled the blog post “Hotel Hantavirus,” referring to the virus you can get from rodent feces. (If you get it, you have a one-in-three chance of death.) The photos appear on Robb’s blog chronologically: the sunny morning, scroll down, the whiteout, scroll down, the rising dark, scroll down, the letters slashed into the door. These pictures and writings are all promoted via social media over the next wi-fi connection she can find.
She sends digital photo files by e-mail to a printer at the Grand Central Art Center in Santa Ana, California. The printer itself sits out in the galleries, like a sculpture of its own. Docents at the museum pick up the prints, slot them into plain black frames, and hang them on the wall. These new photos replace the batch from the week before, creating a perpetually changing art show.
That’s not all. There’s also a 3-D printer at the Grand Central Art Center, along with a 3-D printer at Tacoma Art Museum, set up to receive weekly 3-D scans of rocks Robb has found on the trail, and then to manufacture replicas. The MakerBots click into action once a week. They hum as they extrude hollow, plastic, neon-colored copies of real rocks in the wilderness, printed in colors coded to indicate the elevation where the rocks were found. Every bump and curve of the original rock is precisely replicated, but these replicas could never pass as the real thing. They look like sci-fi candies, beamed into the galleries Star Trek–style and displayed on bright light boxes that set them aglow with a most aggressive artificiality. Yet in material ways, they’re truer translations than photographs or writings could produce.
If artists are the class that materializes what others only imagine, then Susan Robb is following in a long American tradition. Her forebears are the artists of the first American art movement, the Hudson River School, who created the nation, in images, that they wanted to believe in—and brag about. Unlike Europe, this land was not renowned for ruins and recorded histories. It had only “wildness” to distinguish itself, supplied especially by the West. In an 1836 issue of American Monthly magazine, the Hudson River School painter Thomas Cole—who conjured stunning, gleaming paradises where Natives pop up for symbolic cameos—listed “Wildness” as the first among “Elements of American Scenery”: “For those scenes of solitude from which the hand of nature has never been lifted, affect the mind with a more deep toned emotion than aught which the hand of man has touched.” Cole and his cohorts regularly deleted inconvenient scenery—like buildings or clumps of tourists. Their scenery is retouched, not untouched.
The Pacific Crest Trail is a place defined by what it is not. It is not rolling farms, neon lights, or shrubbed suburbs, and it is surely not its automotive analogue, Interstate 5. It’s a utopia in the original Greek meaning of the word, which is not “good place”—as was later interpreted due to a hearing error between “ou” (no) and “eu” (good)—but rather “no place.” The Pacific Crest Trail is 2,650 miles of no place. It has been constructed, publicized, and classified as “wilderness” in the realm of the American imagination. By United States law, wilderness is “where man himself is a visitor who does not remain.” To clear space for this Edenic escape from “mechanically disturbed Nature,” so dubbed by 1940s proponents of the Pacific Crest Trail, people had to be forcibly removed from lands where their tribes had lived for centuries. Their touch had to be erased to make way for the untouchedness that defined the young United States.
Which makes no sense. But the realm of the imagination is full of things that make no sense. It is also highly subject to change, which is, in fact, its best quality.
Oglala Lakota chief Luther Standing Bear famously said in the 1930s, “Only to the white man was nature a ‘wilderness.'” And in his 1999 book Dispossessing the Wilderness, Mark David Spence delivers the deadpan line, “Scholars have recently begun to recognize a certain degree of narcissism in American conceptions of wilderness.”
Wilderness, this changeable imaginary concept, has been in need of a rethinking for a while. Since the beginning of it, really. In recent years, the extremes seem to have become more extreme, but it’s important to keep in mind that both sides have existed since the founding of this nation. Take a current fight over the Grand Canyon. On one side are two (alarmingly unprecedented) proposed real-estate developments: a 2,200-home community with three million square feet of retail, and a pair of entertainment complexes with a tram that would take 4,000 visitors each day from the rim of the canyon to the base and back again. On the other side are preservationists. They adamantly advocate doing nothing. Hands off. They’re unmoved by the argument that grubby human hands are already making marks. After all, wilderness areas are not magically excluded from climate change.
In the July 6 edition of the New York Times, Seattle-based environmental journalist Christopher Solomon wrote an essay called “Rethinking the Wild,” in which he argued that given all these forces, people must “accept our role as reluctant gardeners.” Populations of animals need “assisted migration,” giant sequoias need watering, and certain forests do need thinning, he wrote. We must commit “a necessary apostasy”—intervention—”to show how much we truly revere these wild places.” The comments section exploded, mostly on the purist side. A commenter dubbed Andsoitgoes, from Wisconsin, wrote sarcastically: “C’mon kids! Pile in the car. Let’s go see some nature on life support.” Isn’t there a family trip just like that in The Simpsons?
Like Solomon, Robb doesn’t side with either extreme. Her work hikes the terrain in the middle, which has always actually been steeper and less illuminated.
This is the context a contemporary landscape artist enters today. Robb, whose biotechnological art began to attract attention in Seattle about a dozen years ago, has read all this history. She knows well the late-20th-century environmental and social-justice movements, and the various arts that sprung from them, from Works Project Administration social realism to free-form performance and improvisation. Like Solomon and any other number of thinkers, artists, and writers, she’s a member of a disillusioned people still searching for “somewhere better than us,” as Solomon puts it. It makes perfect sense to turn an utterly changeable “no place” into the one place you need and can’t find anywhere else.
“Only 3% of the contiguous United States is still considered protected wild space,” Robb wrote as the first line of her pitch for Wild Times. Between the lines of her rational description, you can hear the longing. “As our culture increasingly pressures us to maintain a personal ‘brand,’ be in constant contact, and Snapchat every moment, maybe it’s not just our geographic wild spaces that are endangered, but our internal wild spaces as well.”
She asks: “What is wild? Where is wild? Are you wild?”
For Robb, there is an important distinction between “wilderness,” the human construction, and “wildness,” which she calls “something more elemental.”
The first glimpse of Wild Times that anybody saw was the Flash video Robb used for her Kickstarter campaign. It’s still on the website. It begins with black-and-white TV static. The static resolves itself into big letters in hot pink. They spell “WILD.” Inside the letters are flashing images. There’s a man in a tree, a clump of biker dudes, a line of (protesting?) women in burkas, a wolf howling. There are island sunsets, patches of outer space, microscopic cells. Rock and roll. Surfing. Tribal makeup. Piercings. These are the results of Google image searches for “wild.” The images are archetypal and contradictory. Does wild mean girls gone wild or women fighting for their rights? People all alone or people connected by something universal?
One thing “wild” apparently does not mean, one picture you never see, is a person on her phone, typing a blog entry, snapping a picture, e-mailing a digital file. It’s the most tremendously lovely understatement—sort of like the “narcissism” line from Mark David Spence’s book—when Robb tells me, “There’s a tension between the thing that I’m pointing to and the thing that I’m using to point with.”
It’s more like this: The thing you’re using to point with is considered the assassin of the thing you’re pointing to.
Except Robb has other ideas. She doesn’t wipe the land empty the way Hudson River School painters did. Her pictures and writings don’t scrub away tourism, technology, and corporate consumerism. They don’t celebrate those things, either. But it’s important to notice what Robb’s conception of “wild” does notleave out, as well as what it does leave out.
One day in a conversation from the trail on a dying phone, Robb said she worries that the constant broadcasting of social media will have the effect of “undoing that wild space within ourselves.” She added, as if reminding herself, “You are allowed to have an autonomous space inside.”
She’s responding to that struggle by broadcasting and cultivating silence simultaneously. At one point, Robb passed a lake, and she described it in the shared terms of pre-processed culture: It’s “postcard perfect.” She even shot a photo of the lake that one could easily print out and sell as a postcard. Labeled “postcard perfect,” the natural wonder of the lake fades into mass-manufactured blandness, enlarging the void of silent distance between something you experience directly and that same thing reflected back. You had to be there. But Robb went on to write that after she photographed the lake, she jumped in it. At this point, one becomes extra-hungry for knowledge, having been so starved by this postcard vision. How deep was the water? How did it smell? Was it cold? Did the fish come close to her? Did they touch her? Did she touch the bottom? Was it slimy? Those answers remain Robb’s private wildnesses.
Yet it’s crucial that she doesn’t leave out the postcard-vision, or any of the impurities of a media-soaked 21st-century mind and its landscape, even its wilds. At one point, she wrote about hiking near the place where Michael Jackson’s wild animals are being confined in their sorry adulthoods. At another point, she saw a stretch of green hills, and saw in them Tolkien’s—or Peter Jackson’s—made-up Shire. Another landscape was like “passing through a Japanese landscape painting.” In other words, her experience of the land was processed through culture and not the other way around.
She left the city, or did she? Her figures of speech deliberately mongrelize pristine wilderness and dirty cities. “I’m in Yosemite now,” she wrote. “It has a different feeling than the Southern Sierras. It’s like visiting a different neighborhood in the same city. Or, like the difference between Oakland and San Francisco or Williamsburg and Manhattan.” That’s enough to make the transcendentalists turn over in their graves. Robb does not engage in pastoralism. She unabashedly posted a still life of her dinner one night, which was Top Ramen with Goldfish crackers on top. This was not organic, locally sourced, back-to-nature eating. This was full-on fakeness. These Goldfish are not goldfish; they’re barely food. The food thru-hikers eat is not what you might expect if you’re imagining a wilderness vision quest with magically available salmonberries and plants and nuts. Rather, they eat malts, burgers, muffins, pancakes. They have to. They’re walking a marathon every day. And Robb is not the only one online on the trail. At one point, she met three women hikers who were delighted to find out who she was. They read her blog.
In Romantic terms, the wildest thing of all would be for Robb to get some heinous injury, to be incapacitated or poisoned or lost forever, and to make the ultimate sacrifice for her art: the tragic, Romantic death. Robb’s body did break down at one point—to the point where she needed urgent medical attention.
“I wake, turn my foot, and pain shoots up my leg,” she documented on her blog. “WTF??!! I inspect my ankle and it’s bruised and swollen… If I have to rest anywhere, at least I’m at the club med of the PCT. It’s beautiful and lush with wild mint scenting the air. There is plenty of water, up the trail are bathrooms, and I have a phone signal. I spend the day dipping my leg into the cold creek.”
She began googling her symptoms.
Things did not resolve. It was her right leg, and by 4 p.m., it was “not having a miraculous recovery. I consider living at the creek for the next 5 days and then get concerned that I’m also losing my mind a bit.” A touch of madness began to creep around the edges of the story. Then she described that she’d found three guys who will drive her to Big Bear “after they stop for a snack at a nearby malt shop… Perfect!”
If Robb had any internal debate about whether it would be “wild enough” to seek treatment—about whether she’d be violating some Romantic ideal—she didn’t mention it. She matter-of-factly found a clinic in Big Bear, and when she discovered it was closed, crossed the street to an ER, where she was x-rayed and ultrasounded. They told her they didn’t know what the problem was. They told her to rest. They gave her two things she’d never have found out on the trail—crutches and hydrocodone—and she checked into a Motel 6. She posted a picture of the room’s TV with her foot, elevated, in the foreground.
The doctors “tell me they are sorry my hike is over. Huh? My hike isn’t over.”
After six days of rest, most with a relative who lives not far from the trail, she was back out camping alongside skinny-dipping locals on hallucinogenics. The only time she ever found herself afraid on the trail, she wrote in a later dispatch, was when she pitched her tent near an abandoned tent. It wasn’t the wilderness she was afraid of, it was other people.
Isn’t what Robb’s doing the equivalent of Thoreau publishing Walden as “Like” bait on Facebook? What is the point? You don’t go hiking to tweet. You go hiking to leave all that behind. Right? Except that increasingly, geography is defined by social media, boundaries drawn by wi-fi grids. Sometimes the only way to disappear from the place you are actually in is to commit a digital lie, to claim you’re off the grid when you aren’t. You could be standing in the next room from someone, but if you stand entirely still and text them, “I’m going out of range,” you can be gone.
The paradox of the new geography—the new tech on top of old topography—is heightened in Seattle. Someone once described to me that the real difference between Seattle and New York is what people talk about on Monday mornings. In New York, it’s the films and art they saw and the parties they went to. In Seattle, it’s the glacial-lake hike where they casually got lost. The silly trademarked tourism slogan of Seattle embodies the double life: For five long years, the word “Metronatural” was painted in 18-foot-tall letters on the top of the neither-metro-nor-natural outer-space spectacle that is the Space Needle.
Robb has led long walking trips—and documented them—before. In three trips between 2010 and 2012, Robb led a group of 40 people walking 40 miles each in a project called The Long Walk. Its surface similarities to Wild Times are obvious. There are other art-walking projects happening this summer on the Pacific Crest Trail, too, including at least two Seattle artists. Mimi Allin is performing a piece where she solicits people’s dreams and performs rituals for them out in the wilds. Nat Evans is creating a series of sound collaborations with eight musicians who live in various cities along the trail; he was joined for part of his journey by Seattle artist Erin Elyse Burns (who doesn’t know what she’s creating yet), and there’s at least one expressionist-landscape painter, Keegan O’Rourke.
But Wild Times has very little in common with any of those. What no one else is exploring directly is what a technologically enabled and mediated adventure means. When the Seattle artist Eirik Johnson goes far out into the deep Pacific Northwest forests to photograph itinerant mushroom gatherers whose products the very next day appear on Japanese market shelves tagged with astronomical prices, Johnson is traipsing similar idea-territory as Robb. If something can travel so fast between two vastly distant and different locations on the globe that it transforms instantly from worthless to priceless, then where is the real mushroom? The same question might be asked of a person with identities in multiple environments, urban and wild, virtual and live. Which is to say, many, many of us.
A strong current of Seattle artists examines the tenuous links between place and identity. Early in his life, Isaac Layman dreamed of making his living as a photographer the traditional way, going far afield to shoot exotic locations for National Geographic magazine. But instead, he’s building a career out of never leaving the house. To make a picture, he takes hundreds and hundreds of pictures of a single thing—say, a set of glasses in his cupboard—and then layers them digitally so that they are like the highest resolution image possible, something so clear that it feels both mundane and distantly inhuman. He troubles travel by refusing to circumnavigate the globe, and instead penetrates a thousand leagues into what’s in his own kitchen. Robb captures every detail of a rock exactly right, yet totally wrong, and Layman does the same thing differently.
On the flip side, Aaron Huey does go globe-trotting for National Geographicfrom his home base in Seattle, but when the magazine gave him the opportunity to represent Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, he insisted that his vision was necessarily incomplete, and that the residents be given dedicated space on the magazine’s website to submit their own close-to-home versions of their lives and environment. Tech has made it possible to include more voices now that boundaries aren’t strictly physical, and with that comes the obligation to go ahead and do that.
How do we distinguish between being connected and being colonized? Is anything still wild if you share it with other people through corporate-owned social media?
Where is there still room for freedom, and what kind, and for whom?
When I told a colleague about Robb’s technologically enabled and mediated adventure, she said, “I find it horrifying!” In some sense, to be “horrified” by what Robb is doing is exactly what Wild Times is about. It’s not that Robb has any particular interest in upsetting people. But it happens naturally. She breaks force fields we’ve erected to magnetize certain things apart: nature and culture, alone and together, private and public, gallery and wilderness, subjects and objects. We must need those separations, otherwise they wouldn’t persevere so tenaciously. Yet what’s on either side of the divides keeps shifting with time, technology, and perspective. Wild Times is an attempt to experience the epic and the deeply personal, and to document those essentially undocumentable experiences using the most invasive—and pervasive—of mediums. Robb doesn’t leave out the old-fashioned mediums of words and pictures, either, even while proving that they can’t capture many dimensions of experience. That never stopped anybody from writing and photographing, anyway, and Robb is a full citizen of her own culture, not an artist apart. This is the human animal. It Instagrams. It walks through multiple biomes on its own two feet. Where’s the conflict?
Robb is also performing the act of being the artist and the subject of her experiences simultaneously. It’s a performance not unfamiliar to anybody who writes her own stories and turns them into pictures and movies on social media—while living them. Robb’s version is just more extreme, because it’s coupled with a genuine search for liberating wildness in whatever forms it can take, that characteristic that somebody Robb encountered on the trail called being “feral and free.” Art historian Kolya Rice, who gave a talk about Wild Times at the Frye Art Museum over the summer, sees Robb in relation to 1960s and ’70s artists like John Cage and Joseph Beuys, performers both. Beuys would do things like spend a dangerous amount of time in a gallery alone with a coyote, but he also had a whole formal output of concrete sculptures, relics often limited to two basic materials: felt and fat. Like Beuys, Robb is shamanistic. “These artists engage in a kind of chaos, an unformed set of possibilities, but then move that back into the [material] side, making sense of what one has just experienced using organization and order,” Rice says. “They oscillate between those two poles.” Like Cage, Robb’s purpose, as Rice sees it, is “to distance you from habitual ways of thinking.” One habitual way of thinking is to believe that wilderness and technology must be separated to survive and thrive. “For Susan, technology is here to stay,” Rice says. “But you can use these things in really creative ways that don’t necessarily hold to the standard usages.” Essentially, it’s not choosing between dropping out or selling out. It’s hacking.
About 750 people apply to hike the full length of the PCT each year, according to the Pacific Crest Trail Association—but hundreds of thousands more vicariously follow their journeys. Shortly after the trail’s official opening in 1993 was when Cheryl Strayed made the trek. She eventually turned her experiences into Wild: From Lost to Found on the Pacific Crest Trail, which became a best-selling book. The movie adaptation of Wild is due out later this year, starring Reese Witherspoon.
It takes certain means and privileges to drop everything and hike for five months straight. Robb raised $20,000 from an army of donors on Kickstarter, supplementing a $50,000 Creative Capital grant. But what about the other hikers? Their trials and tribulations out on the trail are real, but induced hardship is yet another sign that prosperous Americans—and Europeans, of which Robb runs into many—are always looking for something to do. In that vein, it seems worth noting that the PCT is always referred to as the “Mexico-to-Canada trail.” As if it were a conveyor belt that ran in only one direction, more than 95 percent of thru-hikers walk away from Mexico and toward Canada, according to the PCTA. Even if there’s a sensible reason for that, it makes a striking metaphor: The PCT quest is from poor to rich (speaking in per-capita terms). Nothing in Robb’s writing has addressed this directly yet, but the project does touch upon the way outdoorsy life intersects with socioeconomic realities—exactly the kind of subject the Romantics wanted left behind in their search for the wilderness. Robb commissioned other artists to submit writings, recordings, and drawings to the Wild Times website, and one is an audio interview with an LGBTQ group working to make nature a safer environment for sexual and gender “deviants,” i.e., people “against nature,” as fundamentalist mainstream religions would brand them. It also includes conversations with black women similarly describing the exclusivity of REI culture in a way that’s eerily reminiscent of the removal of Native people from lands that were simultaneously named after them—lands where, in the early years of the national park areas, Native people were not even allowed to be tourists but instead banned entirely.
In Robb’s own presentation to her cohort of fellow Creative Capital artists, she spoke of her husband, David, who’s back at home while she’s out on the trail. He was a white-water kayaker, soccer player, and rock climber until an accident paralyzed him from the waist down and left him with the use of only one arm. “David reminds me to be my body, and to take myself untrammeled places for the same reason that I make art, because both art and wild spaces have the ability to free us from the tyranny of fixed meaning,” she says in the video, which is available online. “The tyranny of fixed meaning” may as well be a John Cage coining. Robb opened this lecture with a projection of a photograph of the new REI flagship store in SoHo, standing a world away from the pursuits REI promotes, acting as much a fantasy of escape as a shop. What do city people get from simply walking by an REI? Why do people move to Seattle to go out into nature and then come right back again? What do Robb’s individual Kickstarter supporters get from watching the spectacle of Wild Times?
Beth Sellars, the curator of Suyama Space in Seattle, gave fifty bucks to the Wild Times Kickstarter (if she remembers correctly). She always wanted to hike the PCT herself but says she’s too old now. “I’m getting my money’s worth,” she laughs. “It’s a vicarious hike for me… It’s painful, what that many miles can do to a body. I remember a quiet little photo of what her shoes looked like from a couple of weeks ago. And early on, she had difficulty with the tendons in her legs, and she has just continued and continued… When you really think about doing it yourself, do you think you could do it?” Robb’s feet are sore every day of her walk; the Hudson River painters, by contrast, regularly pictured places they didn’t even bother to set foot in, let alone inhabit for an extended time.
Sellars says she wonders, too, what Robb’s corporate sponsors including Microsoft and Whole Foods get out of participating in a liberation from “the tyranny of fixed meaning.” Whatever it is, somehow they’re working for Robb rather than Robb working for them.
There’s always a here, a there, and a third imaginary place that’s under construction in Wild Times. Since Robb calls her wildness something made of both “a geographic ideal and a state of mind,” it’s also between “form and formless.” All the 3-D rocks from the trip will be piled up at the end, and that pile will be a single sculpture. It will have two identical editions, the pile of rocks printed in Santa Ana and the pile of rocks printed in Tacoma. That will be the form, with its precisely curved and angled exteriors. But the rocks invoke a formless universe, too, because they force you to imagine all the environments where the real twins live.
One of the weirdest parts of Wild Times has to be “Formulary for a New Wildness,” a series of workshops based in group therapy that have been held at the Frye Art Museum. People just drop in; there are six sessions total throughout the course of Robb’s walk, the final one on September 14. The facilitators are an artist and a psychotherapist.
“What does group therapy have to do with wildness?” I asked the psychotherapist, Nicole Wiggins, when I reached her at her office.
“It feels a little paradoxical to explore wildness in just talk, but I do it every day in talk therapy,” she said. “People come to explore their internal landscapes, often what they find intimidatingly or overwhelmingly wild inside them.”
In the first Wild Times psychotherapy session, according to an account written on Robb’s blog by the facilitators, the participants asked themselves what it really means to say “not in your wildest dreams.” In 1967, Richard Brautigan wrote a poem about his wildest dreams called “All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace,” and Robb posted it to the Wild Times blog in June. It ends:
I like to think
(it has to be!)
of a cybernetic ecology
where we are free of our labors
and joined back to nature,
returned to our mammal
brothers and sisters,
and all watched over
by machines of loving grace.
“All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace,” like Wild Times, is a dream of two realms crisscrossing to create a third, new place, a utopia that just might be “horrifying” in good ways. Along with the link to the poem, Robb posted a picture of what was in front of her at that moment.
Her photograph is a wide, vast view, the top half all sky. This sky is idyllic blue, hanging over the formidable Mojave Desert, where Robb is positioned at the base of a little ridge dotted with green puffs of sagebrush and bitterbrush on the brown ground. The puffs are elongated by their shadows—it’s sunset, a picturesque moment—and every shadow points diagonally across the picture to one thing: a naked, twisty juniper tree. Its bleached fingers gesture to your eye’s final destination: a colony of white turbines planted on the flat distance beyond the ridge, generating electricity. They look like tiny tombstones from this far away, each marking a little death of wilderness. Look at those evil machines, you might think. But, you might also remember, they’re sending life-giving heat and light to someone, somewhere. “Another night of wind farm lullabies,” Robb wrote. If looking at this image, you can’t decide how to feel, yet feel more urgently than ever that you should decide, that’s a Robb landscape working on you.